Lest Auld Acquaintance be Forgot
Anyway, now that I've fallen out with Haloscan, in the interests of keeping track of the comments (if any), I'll repost here what I had said about it in another incarnation:
Some blokes sit in pub, solve world's ills
"You may be aware that a number of people have got together in the attempt to revitalise the democratic and progressive, er, left, for want of a better term, and have come up with a document that's generating lots of heat if not very much light.
The trouble is not just that it isn't an inspiring text - there may be a small prize offered for anyone that can dig out of there a quotation which would have me manning personning the barricades. It is more that, in and amongst the paragraphs with which I would tend to agree, there is a pernicious attempt to equate criticism of American and Israeli state policy with blanket Anti-Americanism and Anti-Semitism. I'm sorry, but that just will not do. Bad policies are bad policies, and vice versa, regardless of their origin. Hell, I was born in Bradford, but I reject an awful lot of the Blair administration's policies. Does that make me anti-British? If so, you'd better have a bloody good definition of Britishness ready.
In fact, there seems to be more about how hard-done-by the poor Bush administration is than there is about the tyranny the Eustonites ostensibly reject in principle 2. Two quick examples, and there will be many more: Why no mention of Uzbekistan? Anyone with the slightest ear for blogging might have heard a bit of criticism for that gem of a state. My own specialist country is Russia, which is likewise no beacon of democracy; I don't know if you know, but there are some nasty things still going on in Chechnya... I guess the news doesn't percolate through to Euston.
There is probably much more to go at, but I'm already bored of it. The last canard I will highlight here is the line that terrorism can never be "understandable". FFS, get a good dictionary, and learn the difference between understand and condone. If you never even try to understand the terrorists' motives, how will you ever hope to win the War on Terror, assuming you accept that such a concept is a valid way of framing the issues involved? You're dooming yourself to fail on your own terms.
It's bollocks, and deserves to be called as much. The Eustonites have got a measure so they and we know how many people have read it and signed. I'd like to propose a measure for those people who have read the thing but reject it. It's not scientific, but it's no less so than signing the manifesto itself, which only asks for a name and an e-mail address. Register your rejection here."
Happy New Year to one and all.Labels: Euston manifesto



